Skip to content
Statistics logo
  • Courses
    • See All Courses
    • Calendar
    • Intro stats for college credit
    • Faculty
    • Group training
    • Credit & Credentialing
    • Teach With Us
  • Programs/Degrees
    • Certificates
      • Analytics for Data Science
      • Biostatistics
      • Programming For Data Science – Python (Experienced)
      • Programming For Data Science – Python (Novice)
      • Programming For Data Science – R (Experienced)
      • Programming For Data Science – R (Novice)
      • Social Science
    • Skillsets
      • Bayesian Statistics
      • Business Analytics
      • Healthcare Analytics
      • Marketing Analytics
      • Operations Research
      • Predictive Analytics
      • Python Analytics
      • R Programming Analytics
      • Rasch & IRT
      • Spatial Statistics
      • Survey Analysis
      • Text Mining Analytics
    • Undergraduate Degree Programs
    • Graduate Degree Programs
  • Partnerships
    • Higher Education
    • Enterprise
  • Resources
    • About Us
    • Blog
    • Word Of The Week
    • Newsletter signup
    • Glossary
    • Statistical Symbols
    • FAQs & Knowledge Base
    • Testimonials
    • Test Yourself
  • Student Login

Home Blog Puzzle: Surgery or Radiation

Puzzle: Surgery or Radiation

Several decades ago, the dominant therapies for lung cancer were radiation, which offered better short-term survival rates, and surgery, which offered better long-term rates. A thought experiment was conducted in which surgeons were randomly assigned to one of two groups and asked whether they would choose surgery. Group 1 was told: The one-month survival rate is 90%. Group 2 was told: There is 10% mortality in the first month. Yes, the two statements say the same thing. What did the two physician groups choose?

Several decades ago, the dominant therapies for lung cancer were radiation, which offered better short-term survival rates, and surgery, which offered better long-term rates. A thought experiment was conducted in which surgeons were randomly assigned to one of two groups and asked whether they would choose surgery.

  • Group 1 was told: The one-month survival rate is 90%.
  • Group 2 was told: There is 10% mortality in the first month.

Yes, the two statements say the same thing. What did the two physician groups choose?

  • Group 1: opted overwhelmingly for surgery – 84% chose it.
  • Group 2: only 50% chose surgery.

This is an example of how the emotional framing of a problem governs what one chooses.

  • Group 1 saw the choice framed as “survival,” and this positive framing dominated the decision.
  • Group 2 saw the choice framed as “mortality,” a negative framing that dominated the decision.

This experiment was conducted by Amos Tversky, the noted Israeli expert in cognition and bias, and was recounted in Thinking Fast and Slow, the book by Tversky’s colleague, Daniel Kahneman.

Subscribe to the Blog

You have Successfully Subscribed!

By submitting your information, you agree to receive email communications from statistics.com. All information submitted is subject to our privacy policy. You may opt out of receiving communications at any time.

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Table Test
  • Oct 19: Data Literacy – The Chainsaw Case
  • Data Literacy – The Chainsaw Case

About Statistics.com

Statistics.com offers academic and professional education in statistics, analytics, and data science at beginner, intermediate, and advanced levels of instruction. Statistics.com is a part of Elder Research, a data science consultancy with 25 years of experience in data analytics.

Our Links

  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Explore Courses
  • About Us
  • Management Team
Menu
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Explore Courses
  • About Us
  • Management Team

Social Networks

Linkedin-in Twitter Facebook-f Youtube

Contact

The Institute for Statistics Education
2107 Wilson Blvd
Suite 850 
Arlington, VA 22201
(571) 281-8817

ourcourses@statistics.com

  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Explore Courses
  • About Us
  • Management Team

© Copyright 2022 - Statistics.com, LLC | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.

Accept